Ally (Italia Ricci), a luxury hotel manager, is a final contestant on a reality dating show. Her winning smile fades when she learns their date will be a Hometown Date. And while she has feelings for the bachelor (Jack Turner), she finds herself reconnecting with her hometown boyfriend (Chad Michael Murray), who owns the inn that all of production is staying in. As the producers set about turning the town into an artificial, picture-perfect, Hollywood spot, Ally finds herself growing protective of her hometown. Ally must choose what life she wants, the made-for-tv "perfection", or what she's been missing out on - real love and time with family.